Trusted Fort Myers Coin Dealer

Your Collection Deserves True Value — Not Just a Fair Price

We evaluate, buy, and sell rare coins with the expertise and integrity you deserve. Whether you're selling a family heirloom or building a collection, Eagle's Rare Coins brings decades of knowledge to every transaction.

Call (239) 445-9028 Explore Services

Eagle's Rare Coins storefront in Fort Myers, Florida

A Cornerstone of Numismatic Trust in SW Florida

For over two decades, Eagle's Rare Coins has been the trusted destination for collectors, investors, and families looking to buy or sell rare coins in the Fort Myers area. Our shop on Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd. is more than a retail store — it's a place where expertise meets personal service.

We understand that every coin tells a story. Whether it's a silver dollar passed down through generations, a gold bullion investment, or a key-date classic you've been searching for, we treat every piece with the care and attention it deserves.

Our commitment is simple: honest appraisals, competitive pricing, and a genuine passion for the hobby that has made us a staple of Southwest Florida's coin community.

20+

Years Serving

100%

Honest Appraisals

SWFL

Locally Owned

What We Offer

Services Tailored to Collectors & Sellers

From rare finds to precious metals, we provide expert services for every level of collector and investor.

Buying Rare Coins

Selling coins? We offer fair, market-driven prices for rare U.S. and world coins, bulk collections, estate lots, and individual key dates. No collection is too small or too specialized.

Selling Coins & Bullion

Expand your collection with our curated inventory of authenticated coins, gold and silver bullion, and commemorative pieces — all at competitive prices with full transparency.

Expert Appraisals

Not sure what your coins are worth? Our experienced appraisers provide thorough, no-pressure evaluations so you can make informed decisions with confidence.

Gold & Silver Buying

We purchase gold and silver coins, bars, and jewelry at current market rates. Get a quick, honest evaluation with no hidden fees or lowball offers.

Collection Guidance

Whether you're starting your first collection or acquiring your tenth, we offer personalized guidance to help you build strategically and acquire with purpose.

Estate & Bulk Lots

Processing an estate or liquidating a large collection? We handle bulk purchases with discretion and professionalism, ensuring every piece receives proper attention.

Our Inventory

Rare Coins & Precious Metals

Browse the types of collectibles and investments we buy, sell, and appraise every day.

U.S. Rare Coins

Pre-1933 · Key Dates · Proof Sets

Gold Coins

Eagles · Half Eagles · Sovereigns

Silver Coins

Dollars · Halves · Morgan · Mercury

World Coins

International · Ancient · Modern

Why Eagle's Rare Coins

The Difference Experience Makes

We've built our reputation on trust, knowledge, and treating every customer like a neighbor.

Decades of Numismatic Expertise

Our team brings extensive knowledge of U.S. and world coinage, grading standards, and market values — so you get accurate assessments every time.

Fair, Transparent Pricing

We reference current market data and grading guides to offer competitive prices — whether we're buying from you or selling to you. No surprises, no pressure.

Local & Approachable

As a Fort Myers-based shop, we value personal relationships. Walk in for a casual conversation or a serious appraisal — you'll always be treated with respect.

Wide Range of Services

From single-coin appraisals to entire estate collections, we handle transactions of every size with the same level of care and professionalism.

Customer Stories

What Our Customers Say

Hear from collectors and sellers in the Southwest Florida community.

I brought in a small collection my grandfather left me, not knowing what it was worth. The team at Eagle's took the time to explain everything — the dates, the grades, the market. I felt confident selling because the offer was fair and honest.

Margaret T.

Fort Myers, FL

As a new collector, I was nervous about making mistakes. They walked me through the basics, recommended a few starter pieces, and never made me feel rushed. That kind of patience is rare — and it's why I keep coming back.

Robert D.

Naples, FL

I've sold gold and silver through several dealers over the years, and Eagle's stands out for transparency. They explained how they calculated the price, showed me the spot rates, and the offer was competitive. Highly recommend.

Linda S.

Cape Coral, FL

Visit Our Shop

We're conveniently located in Fort Myers and welcome walk-ins during business hours. Call ahead for appraisals or to discuss a sale.

Address 4135 Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd
Fort Myers, FL 33916-4809

Phone (239) 445-9028

Email eaglemc239@aol.com